Every organization wins and loses. Few stop for either.
The win gets a round of applause and a bigger target by Monday. The loss gets a post-mortem, if it gets anything, and the post-mortem tends to find someone. When a senior leader resigns, the explanation is ready before the farewell lunch: wrong fit, better offer, never really one of us.
What I notice is how good that explanation feels. That’s why you should distrust it.
Blame gives a founder relief at the exact moment the loss could teach them something. The harder move happens alone, before the leadership team is in the room. What did I see and leave alone? What did I make this person carry because I would not carry it myself?
That is Kind Candor turned inward: honest, direct, delivered with care. Never brutal, never soft. The kindness matters. A leader who punishes themselves has found another way to avoid the work.
Jim Collins called this the window and the mirror. Credit goes out the window. Responsibility stays at the mirror. The same discipline answers both failures: give the win away in full, and stay with the loss until you understand it.
The market, the competitor and the team still need examining. They come second, examined by a leader who has already told the truth about their own part. The leadership team will believe what that leader finds, because they watched the leader go first.
This holds for a project team of four and a company of four hundred, and well beyond business. Whoever leads decides whether a loss teaches anyone anything.
So when the last loss landed, whose name did you reach for first?
