We know the feeling. A candidate walks in and within minutes the conversation flows. Shared references. Shared values. Shared irritation at how things used to be done. We leave the room certain.

Certainty that arrives that fast deserves suspicion.

Attraction is how we choose partners. It works there, sometimes, because a marriage has other things holding it together: time, promises, a life built in common. A role has none of that. A role has a scorecard, a set of outcomes, and a calendar full of ordinary days.

Ordinary days are where the honeymoon ends.

The leader who hired the person everyone loved spends month four quietly redoing their work. The executive who championed the hire starts dreading the one-on-one. Nobody says it out loud, but the warmth drains away. Not because anyone changed. Because the work showed up and the capability didn’t.

Fondness is a lagging indicator. It follows performance. It rarely survives without it.

None of this argues for hiring people we dislike. It argues for an order of operations. Can they do the job? Do they have the judgment, the stamina, the wherewithal to do it when it’s dull and hard and unwatched? Only then does connection earn a vote.

The interview measures how well two people talk. The job measures something else entirely.

Which one are we actually grading?

Share:
Share