One question from Shannon Byrne Susko has stayed with me all week. Would you rehire every member of your leadership team? And if one of them resigned tomorrow, would you fight to keep them?
The first half is an audit. The second half is the truth.
Most founders can talk themselves into the rehire. They know the history, the effort, the late nights. The fight is different. Picture the resignation email from each leader, one at a time, and notice your reaction before the reasoning arrives. Relief is an answer. So is a shrug.
For a hired CEO with a new mandate, the question lands faster and costs more. The board expects performance within quarters. Someone else put the team together, for a business that no longer exists. Every month spent hoping a leader grows into the seat is a month the CEO does that leader’s job as well as their own.
Underneath, the test is expertise. Each leader must be the best mind in the business in their domain. Competent is not enough, and neither is loyal. They should be the person the CEO goes to, not the person the CEO checks up on. Without that, the business does not thrive. It waits for the CEO.
This is where Kind Candor matters: honest, direct, delivered with care. The kind thing is not keeping someone in a seat they cannot hold. It is telling them early, while there is still a better seat for them here or a better business for them elsewhere. The brutal version waits until the board forces it.
The question is easy to ask and hard to answer honestly. Most leadership teams already know which names made them hesitate.
Which name did you skip past?
